A Problem You'll Never Solve
- Published on: Monday, February 25, 2019
- Watch my newest video, "The Secret of Snakes and Ladders": https://cnclips.net/video/pS11TNmUGiA/video.html
Vsauce2 Merch: https://represent.com/store/vsauce2
Curiosity Box: https://www.curiositybox.com
MrBeast’s $1,000,000 Dilemma: https://cnclips.net/video/NkYCWqzBc7M/video.html
Newcomb’s Paradox has confounded philosophers, mathematicians, and game players for over 50 years. The problem is simple: You can take Box A, which contains $1,000, *and* Box B, which contains either $0 or $1,000,000, or you can just take Box B. The right choice seems obvious -- but there’s a catch.
Before you play, an omniscient being has predicted whether you’d take both Box A and Box B or *only* Box B. If he’s predicted that you’ll take both, he’s put $0 in Box B. If he predicts that you’ll only take Box B, he’s put $1,000,000 inside. So… what do you do?
I explore the two approaches to this problem, one based on the math of expected utility and the other based on a logical dominance principle. Newcomb’s Paradox raises questions about free will and determinism as it explores whether a problem with no solution might be easier than a problem with two perfectly valid contradictory solutions.
*** SOURCES ***
“Newcomb's Problem And Two Principles Of Choice,” by Robert Nozick
Newcomb’s Paradox poll results from The Guardian:
*** LINKS ***
Hosted, Produced, And Edited by Kevin Lieber
Research And Writing by Matthew Tabor
Huge Thanks To Paula Lieber
Get Vsauce's favorite science and math toys delivered to your door!
Select Music By Jake Chudnow: https://cnclips.net/user/JakeChudnow
MY PODCAST -- THE CREATE UNKNOWN